Carded vs Combed Yarn: What Is the Difference?
What combing does, the quality and cost differences between carded and combed yarn, and how comber noil is managed.
The terms “carded” and “combed”, commonly used in cotton spinning, indicate whether the yarn has undergone an additional combing process during production. Consumers often associate the term “combed cotton T-shirt” with a higher-quality product. Behind this perception are the actual improvements that combing brings to the yarn. The difference directly affects yarn quality, end-use applications and production costs.
Carded Yarn
In carded yarn production, the sliver leaving the carding machine proceeds to the drawing, roving and ring spinning stages (or directly to rotor spinning) without undergoing combing. Carding separates and cleans most fibres, but a certain proportion of short fibres, neps and fine foreign matter remains in the sliver.
- Characteristics: Compared with combed yarn, carded yarn is hairier, less even and has a duller appearance. It can also have a fuller, bulkier handle.
- Advantages: The production process is shorter and fibre loss is lower, making carded yarn more economical.
- Applications: Everyday T-shirts, sweatshirts, denim, towels, home textiles and products where price is a key consideration.
Combed Yarn
In combed yarn production, the slivers leaving the carding machine first pass through preparatory machines that convert them into a suitable form for the comber. The comber uses fine-toothed combs to separate short fibres, neps and remaining impurities from the fibre strand. The result is a sliver consisting of longer, cleaner and more parallel fibres.
- Characteristics: The resulting yarn is more even, stronger, less hairy and brighter. It is also possible to produce finer yarn counts.
- Effect on fabric: Fabrics made from combed yarn have a smoother surface, are less prone to pilling and generally produce brighter, more uniform shades during dyeing.
- Applications: Premium T-shirts and polo shirts, underwear, babywear, fine shirting fabrics and other higher-quality products.
Semi-Combed Yarn
Some mills use a process that removes a relatively small proportion of comber noil to strike a balance between quality and cost. This approach is commonly referred to as semi-combed yarn production. It offers better quality than carded yarn at a lower cost than fully combed yarn.
Comber Noil and Production Costs
The short fibres separated during combing are known as comber noil. The amount removed is determined by the comber settings. As the noil percentage increases, yarn quality generally improves, but more raw fibre is required to produce the same quantity of yarn. For example, if a production process removes 15% comber noil, approximately 15 kg of every 100 kg of fibre fed into the process is separated during combing.
This percentage is determined by balancing the product’s quality targets against its cost. Since fibre is the largest component of yarn production costs, even small changes in the comber noil percentage can have a noticeable effect on unit cost. Combing also requires additional machinery, energy and labour.
Comber Noil Is a Valuable By-Product
Comber noil is not waste in the conventional sense. The fibres separated by the comber are relatively clean and long; they are simply not long enough for the intended combed yarn quality. These fibres can be used in several ways:
- Used as a blending component in open-end (rotor) yarn production.
- Sold to other yarn manufacturers.
- Utilised in nonwovens, cotton-based products and filling materials.
For this reason, the quantity and quality of comber noil should be recorded, tracked as separate inventory and monitored through to its sale or reuse. Including noil revenue accurately in cost calculations makes it possible to determine the actual cost of combed yarn.
When Should Each Yarn Type Be Used?
- When surface appearance and handle are priorities: Combed or compact-combed yarn.
- When price sensitivity is high and a coarser count is acceptable: Carded yarn.
- For bulky products such as denim and towels: Generally carded or open-end yarn.
- For babywear and premium products in direct contact with the skin: Combed yarn.
- For fine shirting fabrics: Combed or compact-combed yarn.
Separate Tracking of Carded and Combed Products
In spinning mills, blending recipes, noil percentages, quality parameters and costs should be monitored separately for carded and combed products. Recording the comber noil percentage for each lot makes it possible to analyse the relationship between yarn quality and fibre removal. For example, a reduction in the noil percentage below a certain level may lead to an increase in nep counts. This information can then be used to optimise comber settings.
On the sales and pricing side, knowing the actual costs of carded and combed products provides a clearer picture of the profitability of each product. Once all waste streams and by-product revenues are included, the results may sometimes be different from initial expectations.
Conclusion
The difference between carded and combed yarn comes down to the removal of short fibres and neps during combing. Combed yarn is more even, stronger and brighter, while carded yarn is more economical. Setting the right comber noil percentage, tracking noil as a valuable by-product and calculating the actual cost of each product help spinning mills strike the right balance between quality and profitability.
